Roof cargo carriers add room for luggage and gear, but the right choice depends on your vehicle, roof setup, and how often you need access. My best overall pick is the Thule Force 3 XL for shoppers who want a hard-shell box, while the 15-cubic-foot waterproof bag is a simpler soft-sided option and the SportRack Vista XL stands out for rear-opening access. Soft bags, hard boxes, and open baskets each bring different tradeoffs in weather protection, loading, and installation. Read on for how all 15 options compare and which type fits your plans.
Get business pricing on garage and car supplies
- Business-only prices and quantity discounts
- Tax-exempt purchasing
- Multiple users, one account, clear invoices
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- The lineup splits into three distinct formats: soft bags favor flexible storage, hard boxes enclose cargo, and baskets carry bulky gear with fewer enclosure features.
- Thule Force 3 XL is my best overall choice for shoppers seeking a hard-shell carrier; the Thule Pulse 2 L offers a smaller 16-cubic-foot alternative.
- Soft bags range from 15 to 30 cubic feet, but capacity alone does not establish fit: buyers still need to check the vehicle roof and the bag’s attachment requirements.
- Access varies among hard boxes: the SportRack Vista XL opens at the rear, while the GarveeTech and Thule Pulse 2 L offer dual-side opening.
- The MeeFar, WEIZE, and CAMMOO baskets take a different approach: their open platforms suit gear that benefits from a basket, while included bags or accessories vary by model.
| 15-Cubic-Foot Waterproof Car Rooftop Cargo Carrier Bag |  | Best for Rack-Free Vehicles | Capacity: 15 cubic feet | Material: 840D abrasion-resistant PVC fabric | Seams: Triple-reinforced welded seams | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| FIVKLEMNZ 30-Cubic-Foot Waterproof Soft Rooftop Cargo Carrier |  | Best for Maximum Soft-Bag Capacity | Capacity: 30 cubic feet | Dimensions: 60 × 43 × 20 inches | Material: 840D PVC | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| SportRack Vista XL Rear-Opening Cargo Box, Black |  | Best for Rear Access | Capacity: 18 cubic feet (510 L) | Material: UV-resistant ABS | Opening: Rear opening | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Hard Shell Waterproof Roof Cargo Carrier |  | Best Compact Hard-Shell Pick | Material: ABS plastic | Dimensions: 53 × 34 × 15 inches | Load capacity: 110 pounds | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Thule Force 3 XL Cargo Box |  | Best Premium Access and Mounting | Mounting system: Secure attachment indicator with an audible click | Access: Dual-side access | Locking system: SlideLock with separate locking and opening functions | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Asinking 21-Cubic-Foot Waterproof Rooftop Cargo Carrier Bag |  | Best for Rack-Free Flexibility | Capacity: 21 cubic feet | Material: 840D PVC | Waterproof closure: Waterproof zipper with 6-inch hook-and-loop flap | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Sailnovo 20-Cubic-Foot Rooftop Cargo Bag |  | Best for Crossbar and Rail Setups | Capacity: 20 cubic feet | Dimensions: 51 × 39 × 17 inches | Material: 1000D Oxford cloth | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| MIDABAO 20 Cubic Foot Waterproof Car Roof Cargo Carrier |  | Best for Simple Rack-Free Packing | Capacity: 20 cubic feet | Dimensions: 51.1 × 39 × 17 inches | Material: PVC-coated | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| GarveeTech Dual-Side Opening Rooftop Cargo Box, 12 cu ft, Black |  | Best Compact Hard-Shell Pick | Material: ABS | Storage capacity: 12 cubic feet (340 L) | Dimensions: 54.3 × 31.5 × 13.4 inches | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| MeeFar Roof Rack Cargo Carrier Basket with Waterproof Bag, 51 x 36 x 5 in |  | Best for Mixed Cargo and Gear | Basket dimensions: 51 × 36 × 5 inches | Basket material: Tubular steel | Finish: Black epoxy powder coating | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| WEIZE Heavy-Duty Roof Rack Cargo Basket with Waterproof Bag, Cargo Net, and Ratchet Straps |  | Best All-in-One Basket Kit | Basket dimensions: 64 × 39 × 5 inches | Weight capacity: 200 lb | Material: Steel | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| WORKPRO Waterproof Rooftop Cargo Carrier Bag, 21 cu ft |  | Best for Rack-Free Flexibility | Capacity: 21 cubic feet | Dimensions: 52 × 40 × 17 inches | Material: 840D PVC | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Thule Pulse 2 L Roof Mounted Box, 16 Cubic Ft, Dual-Side Opening |  | Best Premium Hard-Shell Box | Cargo capacity: 450 litres (16 cu ft) | Load capacity: 75 kg | Material: ASA-ABS plastic | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| FIVKLEMNZ 21-Cubic-Foot Waterproof Soft Rooftop Cargo Carrier |  | Best Soft Carrier for Rack or No Rack | Capacity: 21 cubic feet | Dimensions: 52 × 40 × 18 inches | Material: 840D PVC | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| CAMMOO 64 × 39 in. Roof Rack Basket with Removable Fairing and Adjustable Support Bars |  | Best for Long and Awkward Loads | Basket dimensions: 64 × 39 × 5 inches | Soft bag dimensions: 51 × 39 × 17 inches | Soft bag capacity: 15 or 20 cu ft as listed | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| roof cargo carrier | Material | Included accessories | Capacity | Dimensions |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 15-Cubic-Foot Waterproof Car R | 840D abrasion-resistant PVC fabric | Storage bag, anti-slip mat, 6 door hooks, 2 extra luggage straps, luggage lock | 15 cubic feet | — |
| FIVKLEMNZ 30-Cubic-Foot Waterp | 840D PVC | — | 30 cubic feet | 60 × 43 × 20 inches |
| SportRack Vista XL Rear-Openin | UV-resistant ABS | — | 18 cubic feet (510 L) | 63 × 38 × 19 inches (160 × 96.5 × 48 cm) |
| Hard Shell Waterproof Roof Car | ABS plastic | Pair of keys, 4 mounting brackets, mounting hardware | — | 53 × 34 × 15 inches |
| Thule Force 3 XL Cargo Box | — | — | — | — |
| Asinking 21-Cubic-Foot Waterpr | 840D PVC | Anti-slip mat, storage bag, 2 extra luggage straps, and luggage lock | 21 cubic feet | — |
| Sailnovo 20-Cubic-Foot Rooftop | 1000D Oxford cloth | 6 tie-down straps, 6 safety hooks, and storage bag | 20 cubic feet | 51 × 39 × 17 inches |
| MIDABAO 20 Cubic Foot Waterpro | PVC-coated | — | 20 cubic feet | 51.1 × 39 × 17 inches |
| GarveeTech Dual-Side Opening R | ABS | 2 keys and 2 straps | — | 54.3 × 31.5 × 13.4 inches |
| MeeFar Roof Rack Cargo Carrier | — | Waterproof bag, cargo net with hooks, ratchet straps, and combination lock | — | — |
| WEIZE Heavy-Duty Roof Rack Car | Steel | Waterproof bag, cargo net, ratchet straps, and wind fairing | — | — |
| WORKPRO Waterproof Rooftop Car | 840D PVC | — | 21 cubic feet | 52 × 40 × 17 inches |
| Thule Pulse 2 L Roof Mounted B | ASA-ABS plastic | — | — | — |
| FIVKLEMNZ 21-Cubic-Foot Waterp | 840D PVC | Anti-slip mat, luggage lock, straps, door hooks, and storage bag | 21 cubic feet | 52 × 40 × 18 inches |
| CAMMOO 64 × 39 in. Roof Rack B | — | Cargo net with 12 hooks, two combination locks, ratchet strap, cam buckle strap, and carry pouch | — | — |
More Details on Our Top Picks
15-Cubic-Foot Waterproof Car Rooftop Cargo Carrier Bag
This bag earns its place for drivers who need rooftop storage without first adding crossbars. Its 15-cubic-foot capacity suits luggage or camping gear, while the 840D PVC, welded seams, and covered waterproof zipper are designed to shield soft cargo from rain and abrasion. The included anti-slip mat and six door hooks give it more setup flexibility than the crossbar-dependent Hard Shell Waterproof Roof Cargo Carrier. That flexibility comes with more hands-on securing: several straps and hooks need to be fitted and checked, and a soft bag cannot protect contents as rigidly as a hard box. Compared with the 30-cubic-foot FIVKLEMNZ carrier, this one takes up less roof space but holds less. I’d choose it for occasional trips when broad vehicle compatibility matters more than rigid protection or maximum volume.
Pros:- Fits vehicles with or without roof racks
- Abrasion-resistant 840D PVC with welded seams
- Covered waterproof zipper helps shield cargo from rain
- Includes an anti-slip mat, door hooks, extra straps, and storage bag
Cons:- Multiple straps and hooks take time to secure
- Soft sides provide less impact protection than a hard-shell box
Best for: Drivers without roof racks who need weather-resistant space for luggage on occasional road trips
Not ideal for: Travelers carrying fragile gear or seeking quick, rigid, lockable storage
- Capacity:15 cubic feet
- Material:840D abrasion-resistant PVC fabric
- Seams:Triple-reinforced welded seams
- Zipper:Waterproof zipper with 6-inch hook-and-loop flaps
- Included accessories:Storage bag, anti-slip mat, 6 door hooks, 2 extra luggage straps, luggage lock
- Vehicle compatibility:Vehicles with or without roof racks
Our verdict“Choose this bag if your vehicle lacks roof racks and you want a moderate-capacity, weather-resistant carrier with mounting accessories included.”
FIVKLEMNZ 30-Cubic-Foot Waterproof Soft Rooftop Cargo Carrier
When the trip calls for bulky luggage, this carrier offers 30 cubic feet, twice the stated capacity of the 15-Cubic-Foot Waterproof Car Rooftop Cargo Carrier Bag. Its 840D PVC, welded seams, and double-layer cover are intended to keep packed gear dry, and the package includes 10 reinforced straps and six door hooks for fitting it to vehicles with or without roof racks. That wide compatibility and large volume make it useful for family travel, though the 60 × 43 × 20-inch bag is recommended for SUVs and larger vehicles; on a smaller roof, its footprint may be awkward. Compared with the SportRack Vista XL, it offers substantially more listed storage and can fit vehicles without crossbars, but its soft sides offer less protection and shape retention. I’d pick it when capacity matters more than a rigid shell.
Pros:- 30-cubic-foot capacity for bulky travel loads
- Double-layer cover and welded seams are designed for wet-weather protection
- Fits vehicles with or without roof racks
- Includes reinforced straps, door hooks, anti-slip mat, and storage bag
Cons:- Large dimensions may be awkward on smaller vehicles
- Soft construction protects cargo less than a hard-shell box
- Multiple straps require careful fitting and checking
Best for: Families with an SUV, van, or truck who need substantial flexible storage and lack a dedicated cargo box
Not ideal for: Drivers with compact vehicles or anyone carrying gear that needs rigid impact protection
- Capacity:30 cubic feet
- Dimensions:60 × 43 × 20 inches
- Material:840D PVC
- Waterproofing:Double-layer cover and high-frequency welded seams
- Security and mounting:10 reinforced straps, 6 door hooks, luggage lock, anti-slip mat
- Vehicle compatibility:Cars, SUVs, vans, and trucks, with or without roof racks
- Warranty:12 months
Our verdict“Choose this carrier for high-volume family trips in a larger vehicle when a flexible bag is preferable to a crossbar-mounted box.”
SportRack Vista XL Rear-Opening Cargo Box, Black
The Vista XL’s rear-opening lid gives it a practical advantage at busy roadside stops: you can reach luggage from the back of the vehicle rather than standing beside traffic. Its 18-cubic-foot capacity sits between the 15-cubic-foot soft bag and the much larger FIVKLEMNZ 30-cubic-foot carrier, with a UV-resistant ABS shell that gives packed items more structure than either soft bag. Tool-free mounting and an included lock simplify setup and basic security, though buyers must confirm their rack and crossbar spacing against the fit guide. It also has a 100-pound maximum load, so volume alone shouldn’t guide packing. Compared with the dual-side-access Thule Force 3 XL, the Vista XL limits access to the rear, but its rear entry may suit drivers who prioritize loading away from roadside traffic.
Pros:- Rear opening provides access away from roadside traffic
- UV-resistant ABS shell keeps a rigid shape
- Tool-free mounting hardware simplifies installation
- Includes a key and lock
Cons:- Rack fit and crossbar spacing need to be checked
- Rear-only access is less flexible than the Thule Force 3 XL’s dual-side opening
- Maximum weight capacity is 100 pounds
Best for: Drivers with compatible crossbars who want structured storage and rear access at roadside stops
Not ideal for: Owners who need side access, carry loads above 100 pounds, or have unverified rack fit
- Capacity:18 cubic feet (510 L)
- Material:UV-resistant ABS
- Opening:Rear opening
- Mounting:Tool-free mounting hardware
- Lock:Key and lock included
- Compatible racks:SportRack rack systems, square bars, round bars, and most factory racks
- Dimensions:63 × 38 × 19 inches (160 × 96.5 × 48 cm)
- Crossbar spacing:23 5/8–29 3/4 inches (60–75.5 cm)
- Maximum weight capacity:100 pounds (45 kg)
Our verdict“Choose the Vista XL if rear access and a rigid shell matter more to you than side access or rack-free installation.”
Hard Shell Waterproof Roof Cargo Carrier
This box is the compact hard-shell option in a lineup that includes much larger carriers: at 53 × 34 × 15 inches, it adds enclosed roof storage without the bulk of the 18-cubic-foot SportRack Vista XL or the 30-cubic-foot FIVKLEMNZ soft bag. The ABS body, weather-resistant design, and keyed lock make it a better fit for drivers who want a rigid, closed carrier for ordinary trip gear. Its stated 110-pound load capacity exceeds the Vista XL’s 100-pound limit, though capacity figures alone do not determine what a particular vehicle or rack can safely carry. The main constraint is fit: this model requires crossbars, while the 15-Cubic-Foot Waterproof Car Rooftop Cargo Carrier Bag can attach to vehicles without roof racks. I’d shortlist it for crossbar-equipped cars with limited roof space.
Pros:- Rigid ABS construction encloses and supports cargo
- Compact dimensions take less roof area than the larger boxes
- Key lock and pair of keys are included
- 110-pound stated load capacity
Cons:- Requires a vehicle with crossbars
- Smaller footprint offers less room than the SportRack Vista XL
- Provided data does not state a cubic-foot capacity
Best for: Crossbar-equipped drivers who want a smaller enclosed box for regular luggage and trip essentials
Not ideal for: Owners without crossbars or travelers who need the highest listed cargo volume
- Material:ABS plastic
- Dimensions:53 × 34 × 15 inches
- Load capacity:110 pounds
- Vehicle compatibility:Vehicles with crossbars
- Surface:Black textured finish
- Included accessories:Pair of keys, 4 mounting brackets, mounting hardware
- Installation:Tool-free installation
Our verdict“Choose this box if you have crossbars and want a compact, lockable hard shell for everyday trip cargo.”
Thule Force 3 XL Cargo Box
The Force 3 XL is the most convenience-focused hard box in this group. Its dual-side access lets you reach cargo from either side, while the mounting system’s audible click signals attachment and the SlideLock system separates opening from locking and indicates when the lid is closed. Those cues can make daily loading and pre-trip checks simpler than with the rear-opening SportRack Vista XL. The tradeoff is that the supplied product data gives no capacity, dimensions, or load limit, so I can’t compare its carrying volume directly with that 18-cubic-foot box or the 30-cubic-foot FIVKLEMNZ bag. It is also a hard box designed around a mounting system, rather than the rack-free flexibility of the 15-Cubic-Foot Waterproof Car Rooftop Cargo Carrier Bag. I’d favor it when access and clear attachment feedback outweigh missing capacity details.
Pros:- Dual-side access makes loading possible from either side of the vehicle
- Mounting system gives an audible secure-attachment cue
- SlideLock separates locking and opening functions
- Lid system indicates when it is securely closed
Cons:- Provided product data does not state capacity or dimensions
- Provided product data does not state a maximum load
- Hard-box mounting approach does not offer the rack-free fit of soft cargo bags
Best for: Frequent travelers with a compatible roof setup who value easy access from either side and clear mounting feedback
Not ideal for: Capacity-focused shoppers who need stated dimensions, load limits, or rack-free mounting before choosing
- Mounting system:Secure attachment indicator with an audible click
- Access:Dual-side access
- Locking system:SlideLock with separate locking and opening functions
- Testing:Tested for road safety and durability at the Thule Test Center
Our verdict“Choose the Force 3 XL if you prioritize two-sided access and attachment feedback and can confirm its fit and capacity for your vehicle.”
Asinking 21-Cubic-Foot Waterproof Rooftop Cargo Carrier Bag
The Asinking 21-cubic-foot bag pairs high capacity with a mounting setup designed for vehicles with or without roof racks. Its eight adjustable straps and six padded door hooks give buyers several attachment points, while the anti-slip mat helps keep the bag from shifting against the roof. Compared with the rack-dependent GarveeTech hard box, this pick can suit more vehicles and folds away for storage. Its 840D PVC fabric, welded seams, and zipper flap are aimed at keeping luggage covered, though soft-bag protection still depends on careful closure and installation. The tradeoff is setup: straps and door hooks take more attention than placing a rigid box on a rack, and the flexible shape offers less built-in structure for organizing cargo.
Pros:- 21-cubic-foot capacity accommodates bulky trip luggage
- 840D PVC fabric and welded seams provide abrasion-resistant construction
- Includes an anti-slip mat, padded door hooks, extra luggage straps, and a storage bag
- Designed for vehicles with or without roof racks
Cons:- Requires careful strap and door-hook installation
- Soft-sided construction offers less shape and cargo organization than a hard box
Best for: Drivers without roof racks who need space for bulky family luggage and can take time to secure a soft carrier.
Not ideal for: Buyers who want quick loading into a rigid, structured box or prefer not to route straps through vehicle doors.
- Capacity:21 cubic feet
- Material:840D PVC
- Waterproof closure:Waterproof zipper with 6-inch hook-and-loop flap
- Attachment:8 adjustable straps and 6 padded door hooks
- Compatibility:Vehicles with or without roof racks
- Included accessories:Anti-slip mat, storage bag, 2 extra luggage straps, and luggage lock
Our verdict“Choose the Asinking if you need a high-capacity carrier that can attach without roof racks and are comfortable with a more involved setup.”
Sailnovo 20-Cubic-Foot Rooftop Cargo Bag
The Sailnovo is a 20-cubic-foot soft bag for drivers whose vehicles already have crossbars, side rails, a basket, or an exposed metal door frame. Its 51 × 39 × 17-inch footprint can take suitcases or camping gear, and the included straps and safety hooks provide multiple tie-down points. Compared with the Asinking, it has slightly less stated capacity and a water-repellent coating rather than the listed waterproof zipper flap, so I’d favor the Asinking when closure protection is the priority. Sailnovo’s tear-resistant Oxford cloth and storage bag make it a practical choice for occasional trips, but the fit rules narrow its audience: door-hook installation needs an exposed metal frame, and the product is not recommended for a sunroof vehicle without a roof basket.
Pros:- 20-cubic-foot capacity suits luggage and camping gear
- Tear-resistant 1000D Oxford cloth with reinforced stitching
- Includes 6 tie-down straps, 6 safety hooks, and a storage bag
- Folds away for storage when not in use
Cons:- Water-repellent coating is not described as fully waterproof
- Door-hook setup requires an exposed metal door frame
- Not recommended for vehicles with a sunroof and no roof basket
Best for: Drivers with crossbars, side rails, a roof basket, or a compatible exposed metal door frame who want fold-away luggage storage.
Not ideal for: Sunroof owners without a roof basket, and small-car drivers concerned about the bag overhanging the roof.
- Capacity:20 cubic feet
- Dimensions:51 × 39 × 17 inches
- Material:1000D Oxford cloth
- Weather resistance:Water-repellent coating
- Compatibility:Most roofs with crossbars, side rails, baskets, or exposed metal door frames
- Included accessories:6 tie-down straps, 6 safety hooks, and storage bag
Our verdict“Pick the Sailnovo if your roof setup matches its attachment requirements and you value a large bag that packs away between trips.”
MIDABAO 20 Cubic Foot Waterproof Car Roof Cargo Carrier
MIDABAO keeps the package straightforward: 20 cubic feet of soft storage, an anti-slip mat, and a mix of short and long straps for cars with or without roof racks. Its PVC-coated material is intended to protect packed items from wet weather, while the storage bag makes the carrier easier to put away than a hard-shell box such as the GarveeTech. Compared with the Asinking, it gives up one cubic foot and lists fewer specialized accessories, but it still offers rack-free compatibility and a similarly broad footprint. The main compromise is reliance on setup: the soft body needs to be secured carefully, and the stated waterproof performance depends on proper closure and installation. Buyers who want a rigid shape or defined loading access should look to a hard box instead.
Pros:- 20-cubic-foot capacity for trip luggage
- Fits cars with or without roof racks
- Includes six short straps, two long straps, and an anti-slip mat
- Flexible design and storage bag simplify storage between trips
Cons:- Soft-sided body requires careful securing
- Water protection depends on correct closure and installation
Best for: Occasional travelers who need a flexible, rack-optional carrier with basic mounting and storage accessories.
Not ideal for: Drivers seeking rigid cargo protection or a carrier that retains its shape while loading.
- Capacity:20 cubic feet
- Dimensions:51.1 × 39 × 17 inches
- Material:PVC-coated
- Compatibility:Cars with or without roof racks
- Included straps:6 short straps and 2 long straps
- Other included items:Anti-slip mat and storage bag
- Model:M-02
Our verdict“Choose MIDABAO for flexible, rack-optional storage when you are willing to pay close attention to how the bag is mounted and closed.”
GarveeTech Dual-Side Opening Rooftop Cargo Box, 12 cu ft, Black
For drivers who prefer a fixed shape over a foldable bag, the GarveeTech 12-cubic-foot ABS box offers weather-resistant, UV-resistant hard-shell storage with access from either side. That smaller capacity makes it a different proposition from the 20- and 21-cubic-foot soft bags in this group: it takes less roof space, but leaves less room for bulky family loads. The dual-sided opening can make loading easier when parking position or access is awkward, provided the opposite side stays locked while one side is open. Unlike the rack-free Asinking or MIDABAO, this box requires a compatible roof rack, which adds a fit requirement. Its stated maximum load is 165 pounds, and the product information gives conflicting warranty periods, so I would check the warranty terms before buying.
Pros:- ABS hard shell provides a defined cargo enclosure
- Dual-sided opening offers access from either side of the vehicle
- Weather-resistant and UV-resistant construction
- 165-pound stated maximum weight capacity
Cons:- Requires a compatible roof rack
- 12-cubic-foot capacity is smaller than the soft bags in this batch
- Product details conflict on whether the warranty is one year or 30 days
Best for: Drivers with a compatible roof rack who want a compact rigid box and access from either side.
Not ideal for: Rack-free vehicle owners or families who need the volume of a 20-cubic-foot soft carrier.
- Material:ABS
- Storage capacity:12 cubic feet (340 L)
- Dimensions:54.3 × 31.5 × 13.4 inches
- Maximum weight capacity:165 pounds
- Opening:Dual-sided
- Compatibility:Vehicles with roof racks
- Included accessories:2 keys and 2 straps
- Warranty:Description states 1 year; product information lists 30 days
Our verdict“Choose the GarveeTech if you have roof rack crossbars and favor a compact hard shell over the larger capacity of a soft bag.”
MeeFar Roof Rack Cargo Carrier Basket with Waterproof Bag, 51 x 36 x 5 in
The MeeFar combines an open tubular-steel basket with a 15-cubic-foot waterproof bag, so it suits buyers carrying a mix of enclosed luggage and gear that may not fit neatly in a soft carrier. Its 200-pound stated weight capacity exceeds the GarveeTech box’s 165-pound limit, though the vehicle’s own roof limit still governs what can be carried. A wind shield, cargo net, ratchet straps, and combination lock give this setup more cargo-securing options than MIDABAO’s bag-only package. The tradeoff is fit and bulk: the basket requires vehicle crossbars and U-bolt mounting, and its open layout does not enclose every item unless the included bag or net is used appropriately. I’d choose it for adaptable hauling, not for a low-profile, simple luggage box.
Pros:- Includes a 15-cubic-foot waterproof bag, cargo net, and ratchet straps
- Tubular-steel basket has a stated 200-pound weight capacity
- Wind shield helps protect cargo from wind
- Combination lock is included
Cons:- Requires vehicle crossbars and four U-bolts for mounting
- Open basket does not enclose cargo on its own
- Vehicle roof weight limits still apply
Best for: Crossbar-equipped drivers who carry a combination of bagged luggage and gear that benefits from an open basket.
Not ideal for: Drivers without crossbars or those who want a fully enclosed, low-profile carrier for luggage alone.
- Basket dimensions:51 × 36 × 5 inches
- Basket material:Tubular steel
- Finish:Black epoxy powder coating
- Weight capacity:200 pounds
- Waterproof bag capacity:15 cubic feet
- Mounting:Four universal U-bolts; vehicle crossbars required
- Included accessories:Waterproof bag, cargo net with hooks, ratchet straps, and combination lock
- Warranty:60 days
Our verdict“Pick the MeeFar if your vehicle has crossbars and you want a basket that can carry both enclosed luggage and other secured gear.”
WEIZE Heavy-Duty Roof Rack Cargo Basket with Waterproof Bag, Cargo Net, and Ratchet Straps
The WEIZE pairs an open steel basket with a waterproof cargo bag, cargo net, and ratchet straps, so it suits buyers who want options for both covered luggage and bulky gear. Its 64 × 39-inch platform is wider than a compact roof box such as the GarveeTech 12 cu ft, but its 200 lb limit is a ceiling to check against both the vehicle and crossbars. The wind fairing and side rails help manage airflow and keep loads contained, though an open basket still needs careful packing and secure tie-downs. It mounts with four universal U-bolts, but crossbars must fit the stated size limits. Choose it for adaptable carrying; skip it if you want a sealed, permanently enclosed carrier.
Pros:- Includes a waterproof bag, cargo net, and ratchet straps
- Steel basket with black powder-coated finish
- Wind fairing and side rails help manage airflow and contain cargo
Cons:- Crossbars must meet the specified thickness and width limits
- Open basket requires careful loading and securing of cargo
Best for: Drivers with compatible crossbars who want one platform for bagged luggage and irregular outdoor gear.
Not ideal for: Drivers seeking a hard-sided, fully enclosed carrier or whose crossbars exceed the stated fit limits.
- Basket dimensions:64 × 39 × 5 inches
- Weight capacity:200 lb
- Material:Steel
- Finish:Black powder coating
- Mounting:Four universal U-bolts
- Maximum crossbar thickness:1.35 inches
- Maximum crossbar width:4.6 inches
- Included accessories:Waterproof bag, cargo net, ratchet straps, and wind fairing
Our verdict“Pick the WEIZE if you want a versatile basket kit and your crossbars fit its mounting limits.”
WORKPRO Waterproof Rooftop Cargo Carrier Bag, 21 cu ft
The WORKPRO 21 cu ft bag is the flexible choice for drivers who lack roof crossbars: its six door hooks attach the carrier without special tools, and the included anti-slip mat adds a layer between the bag and roof. Its 840D PVC shell and welded construction aim to resist weather, but the manufacturer cautions that protection may fail in extreme conditions or if the bag is damaged. That makes it less reassuring for exposed, long-haul use than a hard box such as the Thule Pulse 2 L. Reflective strips and reinforced straps support travel use, though strap placement matters because incorrect routing can tear the bag or invite leaks. Pick WORKPRO for occasional trips and broad vehicle flexibility; choose a rigid box for frequent use or more dependable enclosure.
Pros:- Attaches with six door hooks and requires no special tools
- 21 cubic feet of soft storage
- Welded 840D PVC construction is designed for weather resistance
- Includes anti-slip mat and reflective strips
Cons:- Waterproofing may not hold in extreme weather or if the bag is damaged
- Incorrect strap placement can tear the bag and cause leaks
- Soft-sided construction offers less rigid protection than a roof box
Best for: Occasional travelers with a sedan or wagon and no roof rack who need flexible luggage space.
Not ideal for: Drivers who regularly travel in severe weather or want a rigid carrier with consistent enclosed protection.
- Capacity:21 cubic feet
- Dimensions:52 × 40 × 17 inches
- Material:840D PVC
- Construction:Double-layered, welded
- Installation:Six door hooks; no special tools required
- Included items:Cargo bag, six safety hooks, two reinforced straps, anti-slip mat, storage bag, and manual
- Vehicle compatibility:Sedan, SUV, RV, or wagon, with or without a luggage rack
- Warranty:2 years
Our verdict“Choose WORKPRO for flexible, rack-free luggage capacity when you can secure it carefully and avoid severe weather.”
Thule Pulse 2 L Roof Mounted Box, 16 Cubic Ft, Dual-Side Opening
The Thule Pulse 2 L is the hard-shell pick for buyers who value a defined, weather-resistant enclosure and easy access from either side. Its 16 cu ft capacity is smaller than the 21 cu ft WORKPRO and FIVKLEMNZ soft bags, so it favors organized luggage over maximum volume. The 75 kg load capacity and ASA-ABS construction make it suited to regular travel, while the tool-free mount’s torque indicator gives a clear signal when the box is secured. Dual-side opening is useful when a vehicle or parking space blocks one side. The tradeoff is handling: the box can be heavy to lift off or reposition, and its forward roof position may slightly reduce rear visibility. It makes the most sense for drivers who want a rigid, easy-access carrier and can manage storage between trips.
Pros:- Dual-side opening provides access from either side of the vehicle
- Tool-free mounting includes a torque indicator
- ASA-ABS plastic is designed to resist sun, scratches, and weather
- 75 kg load capacity
Cons:- 16 cu ft offers less volume than the 21 cu ft soft bags in this group
- Heavy box can be difficult to remove or reposition
- Forward roof placement may slightly reduce rear visibility
Best for: Frequent travelers who want a rigid, weather-resistant roof box with access from either side.
Not ideal for: Buyers prioritizing maximum capacity or who need a carrier they can easily lift off and store alone.
- Cargo capacity:450 litres (16 cu ft)
- Load capacity:75 kg
- Material:ASA-ABS plastic
- Opening type:Dual-side
- Mounting system:Tool-free with torque indicator
- Cargo types:Luggage, gear, skis, and snowboards
Our verdict“Choose the Thule Pulse 2 L if you prefer a rigid, dual-access box over the greater volume of a soft bag.”
FIVKLEMNZ 21-Cubic-Foot Waterproof Soft Rooftop Cargo Carrier
The FIVKLEMNZ 21 cu ft carrier combines a large soft bag with attachment options for vehicles with or without roof racks. Its 840D PVC, welded seams, and double-layer cover are aimed at keeping luggage dry in rain and snow, while the anti-slip mat and multiple tie-down points help steady the load. Compared with the WORKPRO, it includes more reinforced straps and a luggage lock, but its listed vehicle fit is broader and its warranty is shorter at 12 months versus WORKPRO’s two years. The bag’s 52 × 40-inch footprint can also overwhelm a small car roof. This is a practical choice for households needing flexible luggage capacity across different vehicles; buyers who want rigid protection or a compact fit should look at a hard box or smaller bag.
Pros:- 21 cubic feet of capacity for luggage and travel gear
- 840D PVC, welded seams, and double-layer cover
- Designed for vehicles with or without roof racks
- Includes anti-slip mat, luggage lock, and storage bag
Cons:- Large footprint may be oversized for smaller cars
- Soft-sided design needs careful securing for stability
- 12-month warranty is shorter than the WORKPRO carrier’s stated two years
Best for: Families who need a high-volume soft carrier that can move between rack-equipped and rack-free vehicles.
Not ideal for: Small-car owners with limited roof space or drivers who prefer a rigid shell and longer warranty coverage.
- Capacity:21 cubic feet
- Dimensions:52 × 40 × 18 inches
- Material:840D PVC
- Attachment:10 reinforced straps and six door hooks
- Compatibility:Cars, SUVs, vans, and trucks, with or without roof racks
- Included accessories:Anti-slip mat, luggage lock, straps, door hooks, and storage bag
- Warranty:12 months
Our verdict“Choose FIVKLEMNZ for generous soft-sided capacity across rack and rack-free vehicles, provided your roof can accommodate it.”
CAMMOO 64 × 39 in. Roof Rack Basket with Removable Fairing and Adjustable Support Bars
The CAMMOO basket is the most adaptable pick here for buyers carrying long items: its removable fairing and seven support-bar positions let the setup change around cargo such as skis or kayaks. That flexibility separates it from the WEIZE basket, which has a similar 64 × 39-inch footprint but is presented as a fixed basket kit. CAMMOO also includes a soft bag, cargo net, straps, locks, and carry pouch for switching between exposed cargo and covered luggage. One listing detail needs caution: the bag is described as both 15 and 20 cu ft, so capacity is uncertain. Fit is another constraint; it requires raised side rails and compatible crossbars, and it does not fit round bars. Choose it for configurable loads, not a guaranteed bag volume or a quiet ride.
Pros:- Removable fairing and adjustable support bars suit longer cargo
- Includes soft bag, cargo net, straps, locks, and carry pouch
- Soft bag opens from either side and folds for storage
Cons:- Soft-bag capacity is listed as both 15 and 20 cubic feet
- Requires raised side rails and compatible crossbars; does not fit round bars
- Wind noise may occur
Best for: Outdoor travelers with raised side rails who alternate between bagged luggage and long equipment.
Not ideal for: Drivers with round bars, no raised side rails, or a need for a clearly stated soft-bag capacity.
- Basket dimensions:64 × 39 × 5 inches
- Soft bag dimensions:51 × 39 × 17 inches
- Soft bag capacity:15 or 20 cu ft as listed
- Support bar positions:7
- Crossbar requirements:Thickness 3/4–1-5/8 inches; interior width up to 6-1/8 inches; center-to-center spacing 7–46 inches
- Compatibility:Raised side rails and crossbars required; round bars not supported
- Coating:Electrophoretic and powder coating
- Included accessories:Cargo net with 12 hooks, two combination locks, ratchet strap, cam buckle strap, and carry pouch
- Warranty:1 year
Our verdict“Pick CAMMOO for configurable basket carrying of long gear if your vehicle meets its mounting requirements.”
How We Picked
I compared the 15 options by the needs that most affect a roof-carrier purchase: enclosed versus open storage, stated capacity, weather protection, loading access, and the type of roof setup each design calls for. I gave weight to features that change day-to-day use, such as dual-side or rear access, included tie-down gear, and whether the carrier is a bag, box, or basket. A larger capacity did not automatically earn a higher place; a carrier must also suit the buyer’s cargo and vehicle.
The ranking gives the top spot to a versatile hard-shell choice, then distinguishes picks by use case rather than treating every product as interchangeable. Soft bags rank well for shoppers prioritizing flexible storage, while boxes stand out for enclosed cargo and access features. Basket models have their own role for buyers who want an open platform, though they do not provide the same enclosed storage. Product details supplied for this roundup do not establish compatibility with every vehicle, so buyers should confirm fit and roof limits before choosing.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Roof Cargo Carriers
Before choosing a carrier, I would start with the trip and the vehicle rather than the largest capacity on the page. These decisions affect fit, loading, and how useful the carrier will be after the first trip.
Match the carrier type to your cargo
Soft bags, hard boxes, and baskets solve different storage problems. A bag can suit flexible luggage loads and may be easier to store when empty, while a hard box encloses cargo in a rigid shell. A basket leaves gear exposed unless you add a bag or other cover, but its open platform can accommodate items that do not fit neatly inside a box. Think about the shape of your usual load, not just its volume. Bulky, irregular gear may favor a basket; luggage that needs an enclosed space may favor a box or bag. If your trips vary, choose the format you will actually want to load and secure each time.
Check vehicle fit and roof limits
A carrier’s capacity does not tell you whether it fits your car. Check the vehicle maker’s roof-load limit and include the carrier’s own weight when calculating how much cargo the roof can carry. Confirm whether your vehicle has crossbars and whether the carrier’s attachment system works with them; a product name alone cannot confirm compatibility. Also check the carrier’s length and width against the roof so it does not interfere with a hatch, sunroof, or other equipment. A fit that works on one vehicle may not work on another, even when both are SUVs. Treat fit and load limits as purchase requirements, not details to resolve after delivery.
Choose access that works with your parking
How a box opens affects where you can load it and reach your gear. Dual-side access can help when one side of the vehicle is blocked, while a rear-opening design may suit a driveway or parking spot where side access is tight. Consider where you usually park and whether the open lid could meet a garage door, wall, or nearby vehicle. The carrier’s opening style also matters if you expect to retrieve items during a trip. A box that opens conveniently at home may be awkward in a crowded lot. Check the vehicle’s hatch clearance as well as the carrier’s opening direction before deciding.
Think through weather protection and cargo packing
Waterproof claims describe a design intention, not a guarantee that every packed item stays dry in every storm. Bags depend on closure, placement, and how securely their openings are fastened; boxes and baskets also need proper closure or a cover to protect cargo. Pack items that cannot get wet in an inner dry bag, especially for long trips or uncertain weather. Keep soft, compressible belongings from pressing against closures, where that can complicate sealing. Baskets call for more attention to securing each item because cargo remains exposed unless covered. Choose a carrier based on the protection your actual cargo needs, rather than assuming all enclosed formats perform alike.
Balance capacity with loading and handling
A bigger carrier can hold more, but it can also be harder to load, attach, and store. Compare the stated capacity with what you pack on a typical trip, then ask whether the extra space would be useful often enough to justify the bulk. Soft bags may be easier to store between trips, while a rigid box needs a place to keep it when it is off the car. A basket’s usable space depends on how the load is arranged and tied down, not only on its dimensions. Avoid overfilling any format in a way that obstructs closures or makes cargo unstable. Practical capacity is the amount you can secure properly and still access safely.
Decide which accessories and upkeep matter
Included straps, nets, bags, and support bars can shape how quickly a carrier is ready for use, but they do not replace checking the attachment method or load limits. Compare what comes with the carrier against what you already own, then account for any extra tie-downs or protective bags you may need. After trips, clean and dry soft carriers before storing them to limit trapped moisture. Inspect straps, buckles, and mounting points for wear before loading again. A rigid box also needs regular attention to its closures and mounting hardware. Buyers who travel occasionally may prefer a setup that stores compactly, while frequent users may value quick access and repeatable installation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I put a roof cargo carrier on a car without crossbars?
That depends on the carrier’s attachment design and the vehicle’s roof. Some soft bags are designed for more than one mounting arrangement, while many boxes and baskets attach to crossbars. Check the product instructions and your vehicle manual before buying, since the roof’s load rating still applies regardless of attachment style. Do not assume that a bare roof can support a carrier because straps appear to fit around the doors. If the required mounting points or load limits are unclear, confirm them with the vehicle maker or carrier manufacturer.
Is a soft cargo bag or a hard-shell box the better choice for a long road trip?
Choose based on how you pack, store, and access cargo. A soft bag can be convenient when you want a flexible carrier that stores away between trips, while a hard box provides a rigid enclosure and may offer access features such as dual-side opening. Neither format removes the need to secure cargo and check its weather protection. For belongings that cannot get wet, use an inner dry bag even when the carrier is marketed as waterproof. Also compare the mounting requirements with your vehicle before weighing the convenience of either format.
How do I know whether a carrier’s stated capacity is enough?
Start with the shape and amount of your usual cargo, then check how much roof load your vehicle permits. The carrier’s volume is only one part of the calculation; its own weight and your packed items count toward the roof limit. A large capacity does not help if the carrier is too wide for the roof or the load cannot be secured without obstructing its closure. Make a rough packing list for a typical trip and compare it with the carrier’s dimensions as well as its advertised volume. Leave room to close and fasten the carrier correctly.
What should I prioritize if I park in a low garage or a tight space?
Check the total height of your vehicle with the loaded carrier installed, then compare it with the clearance of your garage and regular parking spaces. A roof box or basket adds height, and loaded cargo can affect the final profile. Opening direction matters too: a dual-side box may help when one side is blocked, while a rear-opening design may be inconvenient if a wall or another vehicle sits close behind. Measure before buying rather than relying on a general vehicle category. Keep a note of the loaded height so you can avoid low-clearance entrances on the road.
When does a roof basket make more sense than an enclosed carrier?
A basket may fit buyers who need an open platform for bulky or irregular gear and are prepared to secure and cover the load themselves. Some models in this roundup include a waterproof bag or other accessories, but the basket format still differs from a rigid enclosed box. Think about how often you will carry exposed or oversized items and whether you can tie them down firmly. If your cargo needs consistent enclosure or quick access to protected luggage, a bag or box may be a better match. Check basket dimensions, mounting compatibility, and roof limits before loading it.
Conclusion
For a versatile enclosed carrier, my best overall recommendation is the Thule Force 3 XL; shoppers who want a smaller hard box can compare it with the Thule Pulse 2 L. For best value in a flexible format, consider the 15-cubic-foot waterproof bag if its capacity and mounting arrangement fit your needs. The SportRack Vista XL is my pick for buyers who prefer rear access, while the Thule Pulse 2 L makes a straightforward starting point for someone seeking a smaller box with dual-side opening. For specific needs, look at the 30-cubic-foot FIVKLEMNZ bag for high stated capacity or the CAMMOO and WEIZE baskets for open-platform storage. Before choosing, check vehicle fit, roof load limits, and how you plan to secure and protect your cargo.
Fall Picks
fall essentials
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
